Residents hold American flags in honor of slain Provo police officer Joseph Shinners as his body is escorted during a processional on Sunday, Jan. 6, 2019. (Photo: Scott G Winterton, Deseret News)
In the wake of the death of Provo Police Officer Joseph Shinners, Utah lawmakers are publicly talking about reworking the state’s public safety retirement system to better compensate officers for the risk they take in the line of duty.
Utah police officers saw their retirement plans significantly changed nine years ago. Before, officers were promised 50 percent of their income for life if they retired after 20 years of service. A bill passed in 2010, however, lowered that offer to 37.5 percent of their income after 25 years; a change some believe helped bring on our state’s current police shortage.
When KSL Newsradio invited Rep. Paul Ray onto the Dave & Dujanovic show to discuss the police shortage and Officer Shinners’ death, Ray surprised them by announcing that lawmakers are already drafting a plan to restore the police retirement program.
Officials hold a press conference in the Provo City Council chambers announcing the shooting death of Provo police officer Joseph Shinners on Sunday, Jan. 6, 2019. (Photo: Scott G Winterton, Deseret News)
The public safety retirement program was slashed in the midst of the Great Recession. The economy was struggling nation-wide, and every state, Ray says, was under serious pressure to either cut costs on retirement plans or see their bond ratings downgraded.
“We were a billion dollars upside-down,” Ray told Dave & Dujanovic, and few were willing to wait for the market to recover. Our police officers’ retirement plan was seriously cut to make the numbers add up.
Ray believes that decision was a mistake. He says that the state “jumped the gun” when they cut down the retirement plan and that we’ve been seeing the consequences ever since.
Applications from new police officers have dropped by more than 50 percent in Salt Lake City since the retirement program was changed, and some have argued that the change is no coincidence.
For his part, Ray credited most of the problems police officers face today to an increased scrutiny on police officers in the media instead, which he believes have put officers’ lives in jeopardy.
“They’re afraid to shoot. They’re afraid to protect themselves,” Ray told Dave & Dujanovic.
He says that police officers have told him they’ve hesitated before taking a shot that could save lives out of a fear of what would happen if the pulled the trigger.
“That’s getting people killed now,” Ray says. “This is what we get as a result of all that unnecessary — I think, a lot of the time — protests against law enforcement.”
Provo Police Chief Rich Ferguson speaks about officer Joseph Shrinners, 29, who was shot and killed in Orem late Saturday, during a press conference in the Provo City Council chambers on Sunday, Jan. 6, 2019. (Photo: Scott G Winterton, Deseret News)
To Ray, cutting the public security retirement program was just an insult to police officers who are already struggling with so many challenges in the line of duty.
“Worst thing we could’ve done to law enforcement,” Ray says. “We took away their retirement, pretty much.”
Police officers in Utah, Ray says, are already underpaid. With low pay, high risk, and an unprecedented amount of public scrutiny, Ray believes that it’s past time that they got back their retirement package.
He says that Rep. Lee Perry, Rep. James Dunnigan, and Sen. Wayne Harper are already working on a new plan. Perry is also a lieutenant with the Utah Highway Patrol.
Their bill, Ray says, is “kind of a compromise.” Officers would still have to work for 25 years to qualify for retirement rather than the old 20-year minimum. However, they would once again receive 50 percent of their pay instead of 37.5 percent.
“I’d rather have the 20 [year minimum] for law enforcement,” Ray admitted, “but at this point, we’ll take what we can get to at least move it forward a little bit.”
Ray did not say when the revision would be put forward, and it remains to be seen whether it will be passed. Ray is hopeful, however, that the new bill will pass through the legislature and that police officers in Utah will get back the benefits they once were promised.
Dave & Dujanovic can be heard weekdays from 9 a.m. to noon on KSL Newsradio. Users can find the show on the KSL Newsradio website and app, as well as Apple Podcasts and Google Play.
